Why is govt appeasing encroachers on railway land at Prabhadevi? Or did Western Railway defy court orders?

Mumbai has not forgotten the September 29, 2017, Elphinstone Road (now Prabhadevi station) stampede that killed 23 commuters. Nearly a decade later, overcrowding, inadequate infrastructure and unsafe travel conditions continue to claim lives across the suburban railway network. A new mega bridge is also coming up in the Prabhadevi-Elphinstone area to improve connectivity.

Yet, when Western Railway attempted to reclaim its land for infrastructure development, political intervention stopped the demolition. Eviction proceedings had begun in February 2022, and the Estate Officer issued orders on October 12, 2026. But residents claim they had approached the court. So, did Western Railway go ahead with the demolition drive this morning despite a court stay?

And if there was a court restraint, why did Union and state government leaders had to intervene to stop a demolition that should not have proceeded in the first place.

The intervention by Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde to halt Western Railway’s eviction drive at Prabhadevi raises serious questions about political appeasement and the rule of law, especially at a place like Prabhadevi which has a history of a stampede. How many more commuters must die before Mumbai’s railway infrastructure gets the priority it deserves?

Western Railway officials maintained that the demolition was legal. What message does all this send? Can legally initiated eviction proceedings be indefinitely stalled merely because political leaders intervene?

No doubt, the affected families deserve humane treatment and rehabilitation wherever legally eligible. But why was a rehabilitation plan not finalised during four years of proceedings? Why did the government act only when excavators reached the site?

Mumbai’s railway commuters die in accidents involving overcrowded trains, track crossings and inadequate facilities. Although this particular land is required for infrastructure development and organising space outside the congested Prabhadevi station, the larger issue is the government’s responsibility to protect railway property and improve infrastructure.

If ministers can intervene overnight to stop demolitions, why can’t they demonstrate the same urgency in preventing railway deaths? Mumbai deserves safer railways, not selective enforcement of the law.

Western Railway, in an official statement, said: “The demolition of encroachments at Prabhadevi (West) has been temporarily postponed. The issue involves a substantial extent of encroachment on railway land and requires a comprehensive and permanent solution. The Railway Administration, in coordination with the State Government, is working towards formulating a long-term policy framework to address the issue in a sustainable manner. Accordingly, further action at the site will be taken after the policy-level solution is finalised.”

Then why was it done done in the past four years of proceedings is the moot question.

Leave a Reply