
Nearly a decade after embracing private operators to run Mumbai’s iconic red buses, BEST has decided to pull the plug on its wet-lease model. The undertaking, which currently depends on private contractors for nearly 91 per cent of its fleet, will gradually return to owning and operating buses, General Manager Sonia Sethi finally announced during BEST Committee budget meeting on Friday November 20, 2026.
The recently signed contract for 1,500 electric midi buses will be the last under the wet-lease arrangement, she said.
But the moot question now is that the BEST has systematically dismantled its infrastructure to maintain and operate its own buses. Does it have a plan? Does it have money to invest and how long to get back to its original mode.
The seeds of this controversial policy were sown in 2016 by then BEST General Manager Jagdish Patil, who proposed hiring buses from private operators to cut costs. His successor, Surendrakumar Bagde, pushed the policy forward in 2017, with the BEST Committee approving 450 wet-lease buses in February 2018.
The move triggered opposition from workers’ unions over fears of privatisation and job losses. In June 2019, Bagde reached an agreement with the union, which included a condition concerning 3,337 BEST-owned buses, paving the way for wider implementation.
However, starting 2021 it was during the tenures of Lokesh Chandra and Vijay Singhal that wet leasing expanded aggressively, particularly through electric buses. Digital ticketing initiatives involving Chalo also gained momentum.
Under the model, private contractors supply buses, drivers and maintenance services, while BEST pays them under contractual terms. What was initially projected as a cost-saving solution eventually left the undertaking overwhelmingly dependent on private operators.
Delayed deliveries, operational disruptions and concerns over contractor accountability have repeatedly raised questions about the model’s sustainability.
Now, BEST wants to reverse course. But the bigger question remains: After spending years outsourcing its fleet, does the cash-strapped undertaking have the money, manpower and infrastructure to take back control?
Wet lease private buses vs BEST self-owned buses
Under wet leasing, private contractors generally provide buses, drivers and maintenance, while BEST remains responsible for public transport services. This division of responsibility can create accountability gaps, with contractors, drivers and BEST officials potentially shifting blame after accidents. The fundamental concern is that BEST remains publicly answerable for accidents involving its buses without always exercising direct control over the vehicles, personnel and maintenance systems. The two tragedies underline the need for stricter training, independent safety audits and clearly defined accountability, irrespective of whether buses are wet-leased or self-owned.
In Mumbai’s BEST undertaking, the shift from self-owned buses to wet-leased fleets has raised serious concerns over passenger safety, driver training, maintenance and accountability. The Kurla tragedy of December 2024, which killed nine people, and the Bhandup accident of December 2025, which claimed four lives, exposed serious weaknesses in the system. Both involved wet-leased electric buses, although the Bhandup driver was a permanent BEST employee operating a contractor-owned vehicle. Investigations and court proceedings raised concerns over inadequate driver training, while the Bhandup accident also brought vehicle-handling procedures under scrutiny.
