Questions over original planning as the project remains undecided and the expert committee misses its deadline
The proposed Pune–Nashik semi-high-speed railway project in Maharashtra continues to remain uncertain, with serious questions being raised over the initial planning by the Maharashtra Rail Infrastructure Development Corporation or Maha Rail (MRIDC). Adding to the uncertainty, an expert committee appointed to resolve the alignment dispute has missed its 60-day deadline without reaching a final conclusion.
The project is back in the news after legislator Satyajeet Tambe, representing the Nashik Graduates’ constituency, demanded a public hearing before any final decision is taken. Tambe said he was willing to allow the committee more time for a thorough technical assessment but insisted that affected citizens must be heard.

The proposed 235-km Pune–Nashik semi-high-speed railway, estimated to cost ₹16,039 crore, was designed to connect the two cities via Chakan, Rajgurunagar, Narayangaon and Sangamner, with trains running at speeds of up to 200 kmph and reducing travel time to around two hours.
The original route ran into objections from defence authorities and scientists at the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT), forcing a reconsideration of the alignment. With land acquisition already undertaken in parts of the proposed corridor, the project has become caught in a cycle of route revisions, technical reviews and delays.
The planning issues arguably also left Union Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw in an embarrassing position, having to explain in Parliament why MRIDC’s original alignment could not be accepted because of concerns over interference with the GMRT observatory. With land acquisition already underway, the Railways had to consider an alternative route via Ahilyanagar and Shirdi, raising uncomfortable questions about why such a major technical obstacle was not resolved at the planning stage.
Problems from Day One
Problems began emerging over the proposed alignment early in the planning process. One of the first major objections came from defence authorities because a section of the route passed through an Army explosives-destruction facility near Khed. The Defence Department subsequently stated that it had not been consulted during preparation of the detailed project report (DPR) and was approached only after the alignment had been prepared.
Another major hurdle emerged near Narayangaon, where the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT), an internationally important radio astronomy facility, is located. Scientists raised concerns that electromagnetic interference from electric trains could affect the telescope’s sensitive observations.
Although the project received in-principle approval from the Railway Ministry in February 2023, the GMRT issue remained unresolved. In December 2024, the ministry confirmed in Parliament that the original alignment prepared by MRIDC could not be accepted because of its potential impact on the observatory.
The Railways subsequently proposed an alternative route through Ahilyanagar and Shirdi, moving away from the original direct alignment. However, this change raised concerns among residents and farmers along the earlier route, where land acquisition had already begun and compensation had been paid in several villages.
In May 2025, Vaishnaw publicly questioned the preparation of the original DPR, saying that the presence of the GMRT facility had not been adequately considered while planning the route.
With demands growing for the original alignment to be reconsidered, the Maharashtra government appointed an expert committee headed by scientist Dr Anil Kakodkar in August 2026. The committee was asked to examine whether the original route could be retained through technical solutions without affecting GMRT operations. However, the committee has now missed its original 60-day deadline, and a final decision is still awaited.
Tambe, who has been following the issue, said the committee has held two meetings and is considering seeking assistance from technical institutions such as the Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bengaluru. A meeting was held on November 4, and further discussions are expected. Tambe said he was willing to allow the committee more time for a proper technical assessment but insisted that a public hearing must be held before any final decision. He said farmers facing land acquisition, residents supporting the railway and other affected citizens should have an opportunity to present their views.
Years wasted and project only on paper
The delay has left the project at a crossroads. The original route faces technical objections, the alternative route has raised fresh concerns, and the committee examining the issue has yet to submit its findings. For now, the proposed Pune–Nashik railway remains on paper, with its final alignment, approvals and construction timeline still to be settled.
